Perfect! I made just as stated, only I baked it for 10 minutes instead of 5. This recipe is a keeper for sure. I have made three of these now to rave reviews from family at a reunion. Everyone states they think it is better than Wicks brand. Thanks for sharing! Is this from the Durbin Hotel in Rushville, Indiana? If so, they were known for their wonderful food!

Reviewed On: May 4, 2008

AWESOME!!!! These are so good!! I made the recipe exactly as written and got several dozen chewy, yummy cookies. I almost did not have a big enough bowl to mix these in and had to finish mixing with my hands. So make sure you have an extra oversized bowl, or half the recipe. Thank you for such a perfect cookie recipe, it is now in my tried and true favorites file, and will make these for Christmas (and anytime the mood strikes) for years to come.

Reviewed On: Dec. 16, 2007

Very, very good and simple to make. A definite keeper! Thanks for sharing ;)

Reviewed On: Feb. 16, 2007