I'd give this 5 if it were just me. I LOVED it but it didnt wow the crowd as I thought it might judging from other reviews. It was definitely best the first day, the vinegar was kind of strong by second day. 15 minutes cooking time for potatoes is only good if they are about the size of ping pong balls otherwise definitely longer time.

Reviewed On: Jun. 22, 2009

flavor was good but I found I needed to cook twice as long as the recipe stated

Reviewed On: Jun. 8, 2009

These are very good but stick with the recipe! someone suggested cutting the flour by a half cup and they came out way too mushy buttery.

Reviewed On: Jun. 5, 2009