I honestly don't understand why so many people give this recipe 5 stars. I have made pumpkin pie for years and decided to try this one given the amount of stars it got but was very disappointed with it and it was mainly because of the evaporated milk. It made it soooo watery that the pie itself ended up mushy. I personally don't like a mushy pie to the point it almost melts in your mouth when you're eating it, so if that's the consistency you like, go for it. But even after I had it in the fridge overnight the pie was just pure mush as soon as you try to cut a slice. Hated it. Flavor wise, it's pretty good so that's why I'm giving it 3 stars. But then again, as long as you use cinnamon, ginger and cloves, you're safe as far as flavor goes.
Was this review helpful?
[
YES
]
0 users found this review helpful