I made this with my kids. It was really easy to make and they loved them, especially knowing the marshmallow was in it. One quick note: measuring out 5 quarts of popcorn is kind of difficult. Definitely use three regular size bags of popcorn or you'll have too much sauce keeping them together...and instead of being lightly sweet, it's over powering and gets a cheesy taste.

Reviewed On: Oct. 24, 2009

Everyone else liked them, but I thought they were just "ok." The peanut flavor was lost.

Reviewed On: Oct. 9, 2009

Every Friday I volunteer with a group of kids, and we cook and bake. This recipe, although delicious and the kids absolutely LOVED them, is not kid-friendly to make. Creaming that first part of the batter is a bit difficult and we still had gobs of shortening not fully mixed in, but they still turned out very well, and once the flour was in, everything was fine. The icing was a little strong for my taste, but not bad. I would definitely make these again with the same batter, but with a different icing. (When you make these cookies, realize that it's for 18 people, not just 18 cookies. We made around 50 cookies.)

Reviewed On: Oct. 9, 2009