It was ok, I might try it again. I think there was too much sauce, which overpowered to the cucumber flavor. If I make it again, I will cut the sauce down or use a lot more than the recommended cucumbers!

UPDATED!!!! OK, I have looked at MANY punch recipes for a baby shower I am having this coming weekend. I think I have decided to try this one out. I think I might try to make it blue though, since it's for a baby boy. I read many of the reviews saying any jello will work; cut the sugar in half; use unsweetened pineapple juice; try gingerale ... I will let you know how it turns out! I am excited to try it out! Ok, so I made the punch with 1 (and not quite 1/2) a cup of sugar, used ginger ale and left everything else as is...like the recipe called for; with the exception of using blue jello. And it was GREAT! Everyone loved it, said it was so refreshing with the cake (balanced out the sweetness of the cake) and cleansed the palate! So I was thrilled with this punch and will definatly use it again!