I made this recipe as specified with a few exceptions. As other users suggested, I omitted the eggs, doubled the cheese, and upped the amount of half and half to two cups. Oh, and I used shells instead of macaroni. Also, I couldn't find plain Monterey Jack, so I used Colby Monterey Jack. I didn't follow the directions either - I mixed the half and half, butter, and cheeses until it was all melted. Added the sauce to the cooked pasta. I was skeptical as to how it would turn out because at this point it looked extremely soupy, but decided to give it a shot since I figured the sauce would reduce while baking. Baked for 17 minutes, stirred, baked for another 17. Now for the big moment: disappointment!!! For some reason, it came out gritty. Not a hard grit, but a soft grit. Also, there was grease pooled at the top. The flavor was alright. I could really taste Muenster cheese, and I didn't quite enjoy the tang. The soupiness went away for the most part. My boyfriend loved it, other than the gritty texture. I don't know if I'll make it again. I might attempt again to see if I can avoid the grittiness.
Was this review helpful?
[
YES
]
0 users found this review helpful