I use cream of celery because my husband doesn't like mushrooms. I also add lipton onion soup mix sometimes, excellent gravy and roast just falls apart.

Reviewed On: Nov. 1, 2009

My husband loved this, I thought is was good, but not great.

Reviewed On: Nov. 1, 2009

I followed this recipe exactly and I am being generous giving it 2 stars. I seriously do not understand how it is rated so high? Anyway, I will not make it again, but for anyone that is going to make it reads this, Don't put boiled water on top, use MILK instead. Also, you may want to add chocolate chips because it really doesn't even have much of a chocolate flavor. It was just ok once we added vanilla ice cream.

Reviewed On: Oct. 14, 2009