Big hit in my house. Made it for my father and he raved about it. Thanks!

Reviewed On: May 16, 2009

The taste of these were very good. My problem was that they did not cook all of the way through. At first, I tried to take the other reviewers' advice and cook it only 25 minutes, but they were not even close to done. I ended up cooking them for a little less than 35 minutes and they were still not completely done - I think that it was due to the pan I used. I do agree with other reviewers, however, that it could have used more peanut butter. Other than that, they tasted good, and my family liked them a lot.

Reviewed On: Jan. 15, 2009

OMG these are the best oatmeal cookies I have ever had, and probably one of the best cookies i have had, oatmeal and other. I had to cook a few different batches since my cookie sheet was small, and I think they came out better shaped when I did not use the fork to press them down - unless I pressed down too much. I also did not use the sugar on the fork, and they still were excellent. Best oatmeal cookie hands down!!

Reviewed On: Dec. 23, 2008