When I decided to make this recipie our local store was out of french onion soup so I used an altered recipie someone else posted with Golden Mushroom soup and take out the ketchup. It was PERFECT! I would give it a 5 star. I tried it again with 100% the original recipie (french onion and ketchup) and we threw just about all of it out, no one liked it. I would say the meat and style in which it is prepared is perfect, but the flavors of the sauce will make of break this dish, so I gave it a 3. The recipie I wrote down in my book was altered to exclude ketchup, use Golden Mushroom soup and double the sauce to put over mashed potatoes.

Reviewed On: Nov. 5, 2009