I was happy with the result of this recipe (even though I didn't have any beer to use in the cooking liquid). I was concerned because some reviewers said it tasted like pot roast and I definitely didn't want pot roast! I used a sirloin tip and it wasn't "pot roasty" at all. I am sure that if you use chuck roast, you WILL get pot roast! DH liked it a lot, he doesn't like deli roast beef for French dip, so this is great. Was making this off the pantry shelf, so I used canned beef broth, dry Lipton onion soup (which I won't do again, it has a bitter overbearing taste!) and a package of au jus to make up for no beer. I'll buy the correct ingredients needed to try it per the recipe next time.
Was this review helpful?
[
YES
]
1 user found this review helpful