I don't call these whoopie pies. They came out flat, slightly crispy and tasted like a cookie. I even tried not cooking them as long and lowering the temp. I didn't like the filling at all. I was looking for a PUFFY whoopie pie recipe because I lost mine. They did have a nice flavor, just not what I had in mind. Two stars because my 12 year old loved them, but I wouldn't make them again.

Reviewed On: Nov. 30, 2009

These came out flat and I didn't care for them.

Reviewed On: Nov. 21, 2009

Yum, just got done making these. I made two different frosting recipes, because I didn't think I'd like this one. I ended up throwing both out. I finally decided to try making this one. I wish I had done that that to begin with! It went very well with the cakes. I gave this a four star because the flavor of the whoopie pies was really good, but not great. I will make them again, but will probably add some pumpkin spice along with the other ingredients. Thanks for the recipe!

Reviewed On: Oct. 16, 2009