TERRIBLE. Made these twice to make sure it wasn't me. The cookies are way, way too sweet. Those reviews are correct. Two c. of chips is way too much. Half that will be fine if you feel you must make this recipe. Too many chips make the cookie very melty-like and they fall apart, and not in a good way. They required 2-3 minutes of cook time more than the recipe called for. I would never make these again. Yes, it's pretty much a rip off of the tollhouse recipe. I only made this recipe because I couldn't find my one from Joy of Baking on their site. This recipe here, well, it's Friday morning and the only cookies left in the tin are the ones from this recipe. Sad, even my teens didn't like them.

Reviewed On: Nov. 28, 2008

Keep looking.

Reviewed On: Nov. 28, 2008

We ate the marshmallows out of it. I followed the recipe completely. Coconut might be better than marshmallows... who knows.. I was amazed at how much more juiced drained over night. That's a good suggestion.

Reviewed On: Nov. 28, 2008