I agree with others who said that there was too much mint, so I also used less than was called for. This is definitely an interesting salad. I loved it, it was so refreshing although fresh mint is not a taste I am accustomed to.

Reviewed On: May 19, 2008

So delicious!!! I've never had German potato salad before, nor made it, but this was so easy and delicious, and my boyfriend loved it too! I will definitely be making this again soon.

Reviewed On: May 19, 2008

I'm rating this recipe a neutral three, because I don't feel I can give a fair assessment. I just want to note one thing, though: if you are going to try this recipe you should make sure you like blue cheese first! I tried this out because it really sounded good to me, but when it came down to eating it, neither my boyfriend nor I liked it at all. The combination of the mushroom and the blue cheese flavors was just too overpowering (the earthy, fungus flavor). I thought I would like it because I like blue cheese dressing and, you know, the dip for hot wings, but this was a waaaaay different flavor than those. I'm not sure if it was the cheese I bought or what (used Boar's Head) but I will not be trying this again.

Reviewed On: Mar. 5, 2008