The Most Awesome Milkshake Ever 
 
Jul. 30, 2009 1:39 pm 
Updated: Aug. 11, 2009 10:55 pm
Last summer, I caught an episode of Paula's Home Cooking, and she made a simple but tasty milkshake.

I was intrigued.

The recipe itself seemed like a lot, so I cut it in half and it turned out great for one hungry person or a decent-sized serving for two people. Long ago, I memorized it:

2 cups vanilla ice cream
1 cup milk
1/4 cup sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla extract

See what I mean about simple?

You can add less or more milk to change up the thickness of it.

However, the best part about this recipe is what you can do to jazz it up. While this milkshake as is tastes delicious, you can make plenty of variations.

Now, I sorta came up with this stuff on my own. None of it is necessarily earth-shattering (although the strawberry variation I make is killer!) but it just took a bit of tinkering.

I suppose I'll start off with the strawberry variation.

1 tablespoon strawberry preserves
1 teaspoon balsamic vinegar

You can add a little bit more of each to give it more of a strawberry flavor, just keep it to three parts preserves, one part vinegar. Sometimes I'll do 2 and 2. Depends on how much strawberry flavor I want.

You might be thinking 'Vinegar in a milkshake? Has he lost his mind?'

No. Well, maybe, but not about this combination. It is quite delicious. I got the idea from Food Network after there was some sort of run on strawberries and balsamic vinegar. I figured, why not experiment. It's really good, trust me. You can even make the preserves/vinegar mixture and just pour it on ice cream as an ice cream topping.

The sad thing about my milkshake, this one in particular, is that I don't get to make it often. Mrs. LB does not like strawberries so I can't make this for her. On the rare occasion I make it for strawberry lovers, they rave about it.

But I do make others for my wife. I've been making a peanut butter one recently. I just take a few spoonfuls of peanut butter, pour in some chocolate syrup and mix together, then pour it inside the blender along with the rest of the stuff and mix.

Also, I've made her candy ones, like a Kit-Kat one. I'll just freeze a Kit-Kat bar, one of those that has four of the pieces inside, and then when it's completely frozen I'll put it inside a resealable plastic bag, close it and mash it to smithereens with my meat mallet. Then I blend it up with the rest of the stuff. My blender kinda stinks so it doesn't cut up a lot of the harder things so I have to mash it up that way. I suppose a new blender wouldn't be so choosy.

Anyway, I just bought some mint ice cream and mint extract and I think I'm going to continue experimenting. I don't like mint but my wife does, so I'll get around to making this for her. We'll see how it goes.

Now, if you want to see how it's done, look at this. My daughter likes cooking shows and isn't camera shy so we make these shows called Cooking With Yvie. I've been meaning to blog about it and I suppose I will. But in the meantime, here's the episode on Strawberry Milkshakes.

So if you do make this milkshake, please let me know how it went! And don't let the Balsamic vinegar scare you - it's awesome!
 
Comments
Jul. 30, 2009 4:42 pm
yum, yum! unfortunately i am not very fond of paula. not sure why either. nevertheless she is a great cook!! thanks for sharing!! great way to keep cool too!!
 
Jul. 30, 2009 5:48 pm
Sounds great but do you have a bullet blender? My adult daughter, still living at home, and I make fruit smoothies from whatever is in the freezer. No milk, she is alergic, a bit of water or apple juice and blend. We have found some really great combos. Thanks for sharing...
 
Jul. 30, 2009 7:00 pm
Wow! I would have never guessed balsamic vinegar in a milkshake!! Can't wait to try it. Thanks!
 
Jul. 30, 2009 7:46 pm
Thank you for sharing LB, i just realized what makes this different, the sugar! you never hear of people putting sugar in them at all,only what sugar is in the ice cream/chocolate,etc. I will try the balsamic, which I love!! Thanks again! Patty
 
Juliet 
Jul. 30, 2009 9:16 pm
I suggest you use lots of fresh mint leaves- smash them up or moult them. Yum. Good blog. Thanks. My bf would love for me to make some of these for him!
 
Aug. 2, 2009 10:32 am
Sounds good except the vinegar. I don't think I could make myself put that in, so I will just take your word on it. Such a simple como to a good basic shake. Thanks!
 
Aug. 11, 2009 10:55 pm
You're adorable Yvie! We'll look for you soon on the Food Network! Hey, maybe they should start a "cookin with kids" segment! You'd surely be the star. =) Best wishes.
 
 
 
Something worth saving?

Register now to save all your favorites in your recipe box.

My Profile
LB
 Supporting Member (Click to learn more about Supporting Membership)
Living In: Riverside, California, USA
Member Since: Nov. 2007
Cooking Level: Intermediate
Cooking Interests: Baking, Asian, Mexican, Italian
Hobbies: Photography, Music
 
ADVERTISEMENT
About Me 
My mom was a master chef... okay, she was a stay-at-home mom but her food was magnificent and nothing will ever top that for me. But I got so used to her cooking that when I branched out on my own I knew how to make nothing. It's taken me quite some time to realize that I love to cook and to create edible dishes. I've been married for nine-plus years and have just recently dived head-first into cooking. So far, so good! And if you need any tips (not that I'd have much to offer) you can e-mail me at lbueno99 at hotmail dot com.
My favorite things to cook
Around September or October of 2007, I had little interest in cooking and baking. This has since changed. Literally overnight I became interested in making my own food and my wife's been loving life ever since. I'd like to say that I've grown a liking to trying new things but almost everything I cook is new to me. I like to try chicken recipes and add ingredients I either have never tasted (sun-dried tomatoes) or have rarely used before (balsamic vinegar). And I owe it all to allrecipes.com!
My favorite family cooking traditions
After I got settled into cooking/baking, I wanted to start a new family tradition. It seemed strange to just up and start one but all traditions have a starting point, right? So in August of 2008, I decided that I wanted to build Saturday mornings around muffins. I wanted to start a tradition of making muffins every Saturday mornings so my girls (then 4 and 2) would grow up with thoughts of warm homemade muffins every Saturday instead of cartoons and/or cinnamon rolls. With the help and support of the wonderful cooks on All Recipes, I forged the new tradition and have made muffins every Saturday without fail since the final weekend of August '08. My favorite muffins... well, there have been many successes and will be many more triumphs in the months and years to follow so you'll just have to keep up with all the good and the bad on my All Recipes blog.
My cooking triumphs
Christmas 2007! We had my parents, three brothers (two of whom brought girlfriends) over for a Christmas breakfast. My wife and I prepared dilligently. We made a sausage skillet and Farmer's Casserole for our dual main dishes, had bacon, rolls and Sarah's Applesauce on the side, had standard hot chocolate and Hot Spiced Cider for drinks and Downeast Maine Pumpkin Bread, Raspberry Crumb Cake, Molasses Sugar Cookies and regular sugar cookies with Decorator Frosting for desserts and everything went fast! All the items in CAPS we got from right here at allrecipes.com.
My cooking tragedies
Let's hope this is the worst of it, but I tried to make pepperoni bread from here on this site and I botched it. The dough kicked my butt. shame too because it looked so good. And then more recently, I forgot to put milk in some French toast I was trying to make. That was a disaster.
 
Select Your Version:  United States  |  Canada  |  United Kingdom & Ireland  |  Australia & New Zealand  |  Germany  |  France  |  China  |  Japan  |  Quebec  |  SE Asia  |  Netherlands

Frequently Asked Questions What's this?